The Beach House: A Coastal Dining Experience in Grand Island, NY

Top categories (Our Famous Fish Fry Special / Seafood Dinners / Italiano Dinners / Side Orders / Beverages)
Most orders: $10–20

Welcome to The Beach House, a charming American restaurant nestled at 5584 E River Rd, Grand Island, NY 14072. This gem has quickly become a local favorite, known for its fresh seafood and friendly service. With a motto that reflects the laid-back atmosphere of a seaside retreat, The Beach House invites you to unwind and indulge in delightful seasonal dishes that celebrate the bounty of the ocean.

Step into a world where fried jumbo shrimp and tender sea scallops take center stage, each dish expertly prepared and served with a choice of potato and refreshing cole slaw. Priced at a reasonable $18.00 each, these seafood dinners are not just meals; they are experiences to savor. The Maryland Style Crab Cakes, at $17.00, promise a taste of the coast, complemented beautifully by the chef's special Marzetti sauce.

However, it’s not just the main dishes that shine at The Beach House. The comforting side orders, ranging from creamy macaroni and cheese to classic baked potatoes, perfectly accompany your meal, ensuring that every plate is complete. And don’t forget to leave room for dessert! Consider indulging in Frank's Homemade Apple Strudel or the decadent Brownie Supreme, each priced at just $6.00. These sweet treats are the perfect finale to your culinary journey at The Beach House.

Customer experiences speak volumes about the exceptional service at The Beach House. Patrons rave about the attentive staff, with many citing their incredible dining experiences. Melanie Stein shares her delight over perfect fish fries that she orders frequently, complementing the kind service provided by team members like Matt. Similarly, reviews from Susan Peterson and Kim James Yarwood highlight the accommodating staff and generous portions, ensuring that diners leave satisfied.

The Beach House is more than a place to eat; it’s a community hub where customers feel valued. As Jerry Slipko II noted, the calm atmosphere coupled with considerate service makes each visit a relaxing retreat. Whether you're here for a casual lunch or a festive dinner with friends, The Beach House promises excellent food, warm hospitality, and memories that linger long after the last bite.

So why wait? If you’re in or around Grand Island, The Beach House is a must-visit. Call ahead at +1 716-773-7119 to reserve your table or place an order for an effortless takeout experience.

Drive-through
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Melanie Stein

06/10/2025

I live down the street and order fish fry’s several times a year for take out, ALWAYS perfect. This evening I called to place my order for pick up and the young man “Matt” that took my order was WONDETFUL! I can not say enough about how polite, nice, respectful and attentive he was. When my order was ready in a short 10 min he also took care of me at the window and was as wonderful as he was when he took my order. It is so heart warming to see these young kids (not many) take pride in there work now days! He is a keeper, best customer service I think I have ever had! BTW, I haven’t mentioned my fish fry and sides PERFECT!

Susan Peterson

25/09/2025

We had 6 adults in our group & we each ordered something different. Every one of us loved our meal & had more than enough food to fill us up. The service was wonderful & very accommodating. Paulette & Rihanna were absolutely wonderful!!!!

Kim James Yarwood

08/09/2025

07-23-2025, My wife Jean and I stopped in for a early lunch today. Yes, we are Islanders! Jean had a fish sandwich with coleslaw and a glass of white wine and I had their spaghetti and meatball dinner with a side of garlic bread. I think my wine was a Cabernet? Everything was great and my plate ended up empty!

Linda Nye

04/09/2025

Well we had to wait about 15 minutes then we were seated. Waitress very nice. Food was very good. First time coming here, will return again

Jerry Slipko II

06/07/2025

The service and atmosphere was very calm and pleasant. The food was super good, and they were very accommodating to my food allergies. I will definitely come back